Find Ancestors

Agnes in 1881, living in Myton which would tie in with the birth Andy found:
Agnes Coldwell
[Agnes Caldwell]
Age: 19
Estimated Birth Year: abt 1862
Relation: Boarder
Gender: Female
Where born: Leith, Scotland

Civil Parish: Kingston-Upon-Hull
County/Island: Yorkshire
Country: England

Street address: 52 Walker St
Education:

Employment status: View Image
Occupation: Dressmaker

Registration district: Hull
Sub-registration district: Myton
ED, institution, or vessel: 56
Neighbors: View others on page
Household Members: Name Age
Agnes Coldwell 19
Lydia Nordon 51

Here the GRO reference for the Frank Caldwell birth that Andy found: 1883 2nd qtr Hull 9d 279 - the entire page has not yet been transcribed by freebmd but it is in Ancestry Complete index

hi again what you make of the father,s name of william caldwell on franks marraige cert, it sayes he was a merchant seaman, funny he had same surname as his wife, thanks andy for joining in all records you both got are same as i had exept andy,s birth and potty,s 1909 marraige.
Ihave sent off for agnes wedding to albert cert and that first birth potty found for frank and ill see what happens from there cheers for all your help Dave

David

He could have lied about his father on the wedding cert! Many did to hide the stigma of illegitimacy. As for the surname being the same as the mother's, he may not have know his father's surname but might have known his first name and been told by his mother that his father was seaman.

I would get the cert for the birth Andy found and that 1909 marriage one.

Good Luck